Sara Sutcliffe

Paytronix releases their 2023 Restaurant Loyalty Report

Restaurant loyalty is the lever everyone needs to think about pulling as we head into 2024. The new Loyalty Report 2023 by Paytronix focuses on guest engagement maturing and provides crucial insight for the upcoming year and beyond.

Loyalty programmes, born out of simple passion, have evolved into powerful tools for building deep and mature relationships with customers. In the early days, if you loved a product and showed loyalty by making frequent purchases, you were rewarded. Fast forward to today, and loyalty programmes have transformed into what Paytronix calls “digital guest engagement.”

The landscape of loyalty programmes is diverse, adapting to various business segments. Whether it’s convenience stores, quick-service restaurants (QSRs), or full-service restaurants (FSRs), each has its own unique set of loyal members. These differences extend to generations, visit frequencies, preferred day parts, and even the ways in which rewards are redeemed.

Despite these distinctions, there are surprising similarities among loyalty members. They tend to stick to ordering either online or in person, rarely opting for both. The success of restaurant programmes is mirrored in the value convenience store programmes bring to both brands and customers.

At Paytronix, our focus is on data and insights that drive superior guest engagement through loyalty. The report draws from our extensive database of hospitality data, presenting actionable insights to enhance loyalty marketing and deliver more mature guest engagement.

This report takes a comprehensive approach, breaking down loyalty programmes from various angles to provide the fullest view. One consistent theme emerges—guests’ relationships with loyalty programmes are deepening year by year. This growth is especially pronounced as brands innovate new and surprising ways to engage with their customers.

Post-pandemic, there’s been a seismic shift in how guests perceive loyalty. In a world shaped by technology and grappling with rising inflation, the promise of better engagement and enhanced value from favorite brands became irresistible. Over the last two years, loyalty programmes have witnessed unprecedented popularity, reaching an all-time high in membership, with a notable surge in QSR loyalty members.

Crucially, loyalty programme members consistently display a significant check size difference compared to non-loyalty members. This pattern has held true since the inception of the report and continues to be relevant. The focus on the top 10% of loyalty members remains, and for good reason—they contribute significantly, constituting around half of all loyalty member visits and spending. This elite segment is not only more valuable than the average loyalty member but far more valuable than the average guest.


Key insights from the report include:

The total number of active loyalty members increased steadily between January 2021 and June 2023, with FSRs seeing a 16% increase, c-stores a 19% increase, and QSRs a remarkable 24% increase.

In 2022, QSR and FSR active loyalty members enjoyed 5%+ increases in check size compared to non-loyalty members, while convenience store loyalty members experienced a substantial 12% increase in check size.

The top 10% of active loyalty members play a pivotal role, accounting for nearly half of all loyalty visits across concepts.

As the loyalty landscape continues to evolve, these insights provide a roadmap for brands to navigate the complex realm of loyalty programmes, fostering deeper connections with their customers and reaping the rewards of a loyal customer base.

Latest Articles

Explore All   

Optimising customer journeys: the power of integrated tech stacks

In the ever-evolving landscape of hospitality and retail, customer experience is essential for success. As businesses strive to deliver seamless, personalised journeys, the integration of various technologies has emerged as a game-changer.


GuestExperience Management platform HGEM has launched Insight Lab, –a brand new insight consultancy service for HGEM customers who wish to dig deeper into their guest experience data with custom analysis or reporting templates, which will be particularly useful for operators who haven’t got enough time to spare for a deep dive into analysis.

Unlocking the Future of Hospitality: Join the Transformative Event with Industry Leaders

Unlocking the Future of Hospitality: Join the Transformative Event with Industry LeadersIn an era where the hospitality industry is experiencing unprecedented shifts, staying ahead of the curve is not just an advantage; it's a necessity. Join us for a groundbreaking event featuring esteemed industry leaders, including Hawksmoor, Phil Eeles from Honest Burger, Matt Grimshaw of Youda, and Kieron Bailey, Co-Owner at Otolo. Together, we'll dive into crucial topics shaping the landscape of hospitality.

New Technology vs Change Management - Are we focused on the right problem?

Tech continues to evolve and so does the hospitality industry but we still face a multitude of challenges, from rising costs to high turnover, has spurred the emergence of a vast array of technology solutions.

Toasted, Not Burnt.

This blog is all about how the customer journey has been impacted over the past 3 years and will continue to be so

Thiel-backed fund Valar seeds British payments start-up

Thiel-backed fund Valar seeds British payments start-up

Thread good or Threadful? Let's see how the new social media app measures up!

🐦 Twitter, the feisty little blue bird, has been ruling the social media kingdom for years. With its short and snappy tweets, it's the go-to platform for sharing quick thoughts, viral trends, and breaking news. But wait, here comes 🧵 Thread, the fresh-faced newcomer, ready to challenge the reigning champ!

The Future of Hospitality: How Smart Payment Technology Enhances Guest Experiences

Standout customer experiences are key for boosting revenue and customer loyalty. With Dojo Pocket – a portable, pocket-sized device that integrates with cloud-based EPOS systems – you can take orders and payments whenever, wherever.

Is your tech causing confusion, get a virtual CTO for your restaurant business!

Paytronix release 2023 Online Ordering Report

Who is ordering the most online and who is our most loyal demographic ? Find out with the latest Paytronix Online Ordering Report.

Ordermark U.S. business sold to Urban Piper

No CTO, No problem. Plugging the “ Tech Gap” for midmarket operators.

Limber release a study into flexible working trends in 2023

Marketplace partners HGEM consumer survey finds 1/3 customers not happy with payments in hospitality

Honest Burgers crowdfunding passes £2m mark

Feed It Back reports that complaint resolutions using recovery vouchers increase revisit rates

HRC announces partnership with Tech on Toast

GigPig teams up with Uber to provide its artists with safe transport home

A three-month pilot scheme offering local musicians half price transport home after late-night gigs is being launched in Manchester, thanks to a partnership between live music marketplace GigPig and Uber.

Get Your FREE Tech Audit with Tech on Toast

Get a first look at new restaurant tech research from Vita Mojo

2022-23 Email Marketing Report by Stampede

40% of Consumers Now Prefer to Place Their Delivery and Takeout Orders Via a Restaurant’s App or Website

40% of Consumers Now Prefer to Place Their Delivery and Takeout Orders Via a Restaurant’s App or Website

Earn As You Learn With Tech On Toast

Operators are asked to attend events, take part in content creation both for suppliers and for the industry and its important that they are rewarded for doing so. We all talk about the lack of capacity at operators disposal to support outside of their roles, but rarely do we reward them or our partners.